Group A · Match 08

ELA (Henry David Thoreau) vs ARTS (Dante Alighieri)

Result 1-1. Outcome: Draw.

Result1-1
OutcomeDraw
DiscourseB 0.859
AestheticB 0.863
Checked moves34
Bead passes23

Realtime Call

Turn 1
0-0
Kickoff

  1. 0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · John Maynard Smith · Question

    Turn 1. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  2. 0-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Dante Alighieri · Move

    Turn 2. Pass. "Or ere that work engag'd me, I did hold Christ's nature merely human, with such faith Contented."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  3. 0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Julian Huxley · Answer

    Turn 3. Bishop answers: "It is beginning to reach down from observation to experimental analysis, and from experimental analysis to grasp of principle."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  4. 0-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Isaac Asimov · Answer

    Turn 4. Bishop answers: "There had been another change, though, that was significant enough and that was in the colors."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  5. 0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

    Turn 5. Bishop answers: "Julian Huxley framed this well; the inference is that we should move here."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  6. 0-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · James Baldwin · Question

    Turn 6. Knight asks: "What assumption are we testing if Isaac Asimov keeps the focus here?"

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  7. 0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Julian Huxley · Answer

    Turn 7. Bishop answers: "In pre-human evolution, the blind chances of variation and the blind sifting of natural selection have directed the course of evolution and of progress."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  8. 0-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Emily Dickinson · Move

    Turn 8. Advance. Queen Emily Dickinson develops the line.

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  9. 0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Buddha · Move

    Turn 9. Pass. Julian Huxley releases to Queen Buddha, who re-centers the question.

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  10. 0-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Francis Bacon · Answer

    Turn 10. Bishop answers: "Certainly, it is heaven upon earth, to have a man's mind move in charity, rest in providence, and turn upon the poles of truth."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  11. 0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

    Turn 11. Bishop answers: "That means the stronger reading is likely in this direction."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  12. 0-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Emily Dickinson · Move

    Turn 12. Advance. Queen Emily Dickinson develops the line.

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  13. 0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

    Turn 13. Bishop answers: "That means the stronger reading is likely in this direction under pressure."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  14. 0-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Dante Alighieri · Move

    Turn 14. Advance. "It answer to his question none return'd, But of our country and our kind of life Demanded."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  15. 0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Buddha · Move

    Turn 15. Advance. Stephen Jay Gould releases to Queen Buddha, who develops the line.

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  16. 0-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Francis Bacon · Answer

    Turn 16. Bishop answers: "The reason was, because the religion of the heathen, consisted rather in rites and ceremonies, than in any constant belief."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  17. 0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Buddha · Move

    Turn 17. Challenge. Checked Queen Buddha tests the opposing line.

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  18. 0-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Isaac Asimov · Answer

    Turn 18. Bishop answers: "Good Lord, what man in Robotics has not been investigated and cleared to death by your people."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  19. 0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · John Maynard Smith · Question

    Turn 19. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  20. 0-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Dante Alighieri · Move

    Turn 20. Advance. "That ignoble life, Which made them vile before, now makes them dark, And to all knowledge indiscernible."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  21. 1-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

    Turn 21. Bishop answers: "That means the stronger reading is likely in this direction under pressure."

    \n

    The score moves to 1-0.

  22. 1-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Isaac Asimov · Answer

    Turn 22. Bishop answers: "Elias Lynn was a large man, almost charmingly homely, with pale blue eyes that bulged a bit."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  23. 1-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · John Maynard Smith · Question

    Turn 23. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  24. 1-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Emily Dickinson · Move

    Turn 24. Advance. Isaac Asimov releases to Queen Emily Dickinson, who develops the line.

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  25. 1-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · John Maynard Smith · Question

    Turn 25. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  26. 1-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Dante Alighieri · Move

    Turn 26. Pass. "Thou arguest; if the good intent remain; What reason that another's violence Should stint the measure of my fair desert".

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  27. 1-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Julian Huxley · Answer

    Turn 27. Bishop answers: "The one, that is to say, remained in essence a quantitative change so far as concerns the real life of man; the other can be a qualitative change."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  28. 1-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Dante Alighieri · Move

    Turn 28. Advance. "Or ere that work engag'd me, I did hold Christ's nature merely human, with such faith Contented."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  29. 1-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Henry David Thoreau · Move

    Turn 29. Advance. Julian Huxley releases to King Henry David Thoreau, who develops the line.

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  30. 1-0 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Emily Dickinson · Move

    Turn 30. Pass. Queen Emily Dickinson re-centers the question.

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  31. 1-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Henry David Thoreau · Move

    Turn 31. Challenge. Checked King Henry David Thoreau tests the opposing line.

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  32. 1-1 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Emily Dickinson · Move

    Turn 32. Claim. Checked Queen Emily Dickinson presses a claim.

    \n

    The score moves to 1-1.

  33. 1-1 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Julian Huxley · Answer

    Turn 33. Bishop answers: "Men are educated to be self-reliant and enterprising in the details of life, but dependent, unreflective, _laissez-faire_ about life itself."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  34. 1-1 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Francis Bacon · Answer

    Turn 34. Bishop answers: "I have enlarged them, both in Number, and Weight; So that they are indeed a New Worke."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  35. 1-1 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

    Turn 35. Bishop answers: "Julian Huxley framed this well; the inference is that we should move here."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  36. 1-1 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Francis Bacon · Answer

    Turn 36. Bishop answers: "Tiberius in dissimulation; as Tacitus saith of him, Jam Tiberium vires et corpus, non dissimulatio, deserebant."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  37. 1-1 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

    Turn 37. Bishop answers: "That means the stronger reading is likely in this direction under pressure."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  38. 1-1 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Isaac Asimov · Answer

    Turn 38. Bishop answers: "Over there, They were "We" (in the appropriate language) and We were "They." Scarcely anyone gave thought to such things any more."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  39. 1-1 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Buddha · Move

    Turn 39. Advance. Stephen Jay Gould releases to Queen Buddha, who develops the line.

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  40. 1-1 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Emily Dickinson · Move

    Turn 40. Save. Queen Emily Dickinson is denied closure.

    \n

    Closure is delayed at 1-1.

  41. 1-1 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · John Maynard Smith · Question

    Turn 41. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  42. 1-1 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Isaac Asimov · Answer

    Turn 42. Bishop answers: "There had been another change, though, that was significant enough and that was in the colors."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  43. 1-1 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · John Maynard Smith · Question

    Turn 43. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  44. 1-1 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Francis Bacon · Answer

    Turn 44. Bishop answers: "Certainly, it is heaven upon earth, to have a man's mind move in charity, rest in providence, and turn upon the poles of truth."

    \n

    Closure is delayed at 1-1.

  45. 1-1 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · John Maynard Smith · Question

    Turn 45. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  46. 1-1 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Dante Alighieri · Move

    Turn 46. Advance. "It answer to his question none return'd, But of our country and our kind of life Demanded."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  47. 1-1 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · John Maynard Smith · Question

    Turn 47. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  48. 1-1 · ARTS (Dante Alighieri) · Francis Bacon · Answer

    Turn 48. Bishop answers: "The reason was, because the religion of the heathen, consisted rather in rites and ceremonies, than in any constant belief."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

Board Record

Match Shape

Discourse B (0.859); aesthetic B (0.863); repetition 0.274. Move mix: 7 pass, 22 advance, 15 challenge, 2 claim, 2 save.

Full Call Sheet

TurnScoreActionCallRelevance
10-0PassKnight John Maynard Smith re-centers the question.0.749
20-0PassKing Dante Alighieri re-centers the question.0.886
30-0PassBishop Julian Huxley re-centers the question.0.906
40-0AdvanceDante Alighieri releases to Bishop Isaac Asimov, who develops the line.0.827
50-0AdvanceJulian Huxley releases to Bishop Stephen Jay Gould, who develops the line.0.887
60-0ChallengeIsaac Asimov releases to Knight James Baldwin, who tests the opposing line.0.814
70-0ChallengeStephen Jay Gould releases to Bishop Julian Huxley, who tests the opposing line.0.717
80-0AdvanceQueen Emily Dickinson develops the line.0.971
90-0PassJulian Huxley releases to Queen Buddha, who re-centers the question.0.876
100-0AdvanceBishop Francis Bacon develops the line.0.894
110-0AdvanceBishop Stephen Jay Gould develops the line.1.000
120-0AdvanceQueen Emily Dickinson develops the line.1.000
130-0ChallengeChecked Bishop Stephen Jay Gould tests the opposing line.0.990
140-0AdvanceKing Dante Alighieri develops the line.0.945
150-0AdvanceStephen Jay Gould releases to Queen Buddha, who develops the line.1.000
160-0AdvanceBishop Francis Bacon develops the line.1.000
170-0ChallengeChecked Queen Buddha tests the opposing line.0.937
180-0AdvanceFrancis Bacon releases to Bishop Isaac Asimov, who develops the line.1.000
190-0ChallengeBuddha releases to Knight John Maynard Smith, who tests the opposing line.0.895
200-0AdvanceIsaac Asimov releases to King Dante Alighieri, who develops the line.0.870
211-0ClaimJohn Maynard Smith releases to Bishop Stephen Jay Gould, who presses a claim.1.000
221-0AdvanceDante Alighieri releases to Bishop Isaac Asimov, who develops the line.0.972
231-0ChallengeKnight John Maynard Smith tests the opposing line.1.000
241-0AdvanceIsaac Asimov releases to Queen Emily Dickinson, who develops the line.0.990
251-0ChallengeChecked Knight John Maynard Smith tests the opposing line.0.999
261-0PassEmily Dickinson releases to King Dante Alighieri, who re-centers the question.1.000
271-0PassJohn Maynard Smith releases to Bishop Julian Huxley, who re-centers the question.0.885
281-0AdvanceChecked King Dante Alighieri develops the line.0.964
291-0AdvanceJulian Huxley releases to King Henry David Thoreau, who develops the line.0.910
301-0PassQueen Emily Dickinson re-centers the question.1.000
311-0ChallengeChecked King Henry David Thoreau tests the opposing line.1.000
321-1ClaimChecked Queen Emily Dickinson presses a claim.1.000
331-1ChallengeHenry David Thoreau releases to Bishop Julian Huxley, who tests the opposing line.0.853
341-1AdvanceBishop Francis Bacon develops the line.0.960
351-1ChallengeJulian Huxley releases to Bishop Stephen Jay Gould, who tests the opposing line.0.834
361-1ChallengeChecked Bishop Francis Bacon tests the opposing line.1.000
371-1AdvanceChecked Bishop Stephen Jay Gould develops the line.1.000
381-1ChallengeFrancis Bacon releases to Bishop Isaac Asimov, who tests the opposing line.1.000
391-1AdvanceStephen Jay Gould releases to Queen Buddha, who develops the line.0.907
401-1SaveQueen Emily Dickinson is denied closure.0.833
411-1ChallengeBuddha releases to Knight John Maynard Smith, who tests the opposing line.0.942
421-1ChallengeEmily Dickinson releases to Bishop Isaac Asimov, who tests the opposing line.0.892
431-1AdvanceChecked Knight John Maynard Smith develops the line.1.000
441-1SaveBishop Francis Bacon is denied closure.0.910
451-1ChallengeChecked Knight John Maynard Smith tests the opposing line.0.911
461-1AdvanceFrancis Bacon releases to King Dante Alighieri, who develops the line.1.000
471-1AdvanceChecked Knight John Maynard Smith develops the line.0.833
481-1AdvanceDante Alighieri releases to Bishop Francis Bacon, who develops the line.0.974