Group B · Match 16

META (Augustine of Hippo) vs SOC (Jane Addams)

Result 1-3. Outcome: SOC (Jane Addams).

Result1-3

OutcomeSOC (Jane Addams)

DiscourseB 0.850

AestheticB 0.862

Checked moves38

Bead passes21

Realtime Call

Turn 1

0-0

Kickoff

Speed

0-0 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Omar Khayyam · Answer

Turn 1. Bishop answers: "That means the stronger reading is likely in this direction."
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Desiderius Erasmus · Answer

Turn 2. Bishop answers: "But the nature of this work is such, that it receives addition as often as it is revised."
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Teresa of Avila · Move

Turn 3. Pass. "I am not surprised; for the soul has reason enough, and more than enough, for its joy."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Desiderius Erasmus · Answer

Turn 4. Bishop answers: "Nor in truth can it be rightly inferred, _This Confession is of human ordinance, therefore Christ is not its Author_."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Augustine of Hippo · Move

Turn 5. Advance. "Where then did they know this happy life, save where they know the truth also".
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Desiderius Erasmus · Answer

Turn 6. Bishop answers: "And not without cause, for when were the Grecian Demosthenes or Roman Cicero ever guilty of the like."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Augustine of Hippo · Move

Turn 7. Pass. "Human friendship also is endeared with a sweet tie, by reason of the unity formed of many souls."
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Desiderius Erasmus · Answer

Turn 8. Bishop answers: "But who are they that for no other reason but that they were weary of life have hastened their own fate."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Augustine of Hippo · Move

Turn 9. Advance. "See where the impotent soul lies along, that is not yet stayed up by the solidity of truth!"
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Desiderius Erasmus · Answer

Turn 10. Bishop answers: "But the nature of this work is such, that it receives addition as often as it is revised."
\n
The score moves to 0-1.
0-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Aleister Crowley · Answer

Turn 11. Bishop answers: "But though I be Their frenzy of glee, I am also the passionless soul of the sea!"
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Paulo Freire · Answer

Turn 12. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Aleister Crowley · Answer

Turn 13. Bishop answers: "The Blood of the Osiris" was his word: (Meaning the Christ?) "The life, the tears, the tomb!"
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Paulo Freire · Answer

Turn 14. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Plato · Question

Turn 15. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Mary Wollstonecraft · Move

Turn 16. Pass. "For surely, sir, you will not assert, that a duty can be binding which is not founded on reason".
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Omar Khayyam · Answer

Turn 17. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Jane Addams · Move

Turn 18. Advance. "We have come to have an enormous interest in human life as such, accompanied by confidence in its essential soundness."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Aleister Crowley · Answer

Turn 19. Bishop answers: "I am the priest, the sacrifice, the shrine, I am the love and life of the divine!"
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Paulo Freire · Answer

Turn 20. Bishop answers: "Jane Addams framed this well; the inference is that we should move here."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Augustine of Hippo · Move

Turn 21. Advance. "And not being able to see these in the mind, I thought I could not see my mind."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Mary Wollstonecraft · Move

Turn 22. Advance. "Who made man the exclusive judge, if woman partake with him the gift of reason".
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Augustine of Hippo · Move

Turn 23. Challenge. "Where then did they know this happy life, save where they know the truth also".
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Mary Wollstonecraft · Move

Turn 24. Challenge. "It was shortly after this, that she commenced the work to which these remarks are prefixed."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Omar Khayyam · Answer

Turn 25. Bishop answers: "Augustine of Hippo framed this well; the inference is that we should move here."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · John Maynard Keynes · Question

Turn 26. Knight asks: "Will the charm work still, when the stock of statesmen's credibility, accumulated before these times, is getting exhausted?"
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Aleister Crowley · Answer

Turn 27. Bishop answers: "Learn this, as we pass through the portico: Fear nothing; there is nothing you can know!"
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · John Maynard Keynes · Question

Turn 28. Knight asks: "But they cannot work properly if the money, which they assume as a stable measuring-rod, is undependable?"
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
1-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Omar Khayyam · Answer

Turn 29. Bishop answers: "Let’s take that test seriously; here is how it holds together."
\n
The score moves to 1-1.
1-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · John Maynard Keynes · Question

Turn 30. Knight asks: "To recall the reader's mind to the exact facts, I refer him to the table on the next page?"
\n
The move answers pressure.
1-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Aleister Crowley · Answer

Turn 31. Bishop answers: "But though I be Their frenzy of glee, I am also the passionless soul of the sea!"
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
1-1 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Paulo Freire · Answer

Turn 32. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
1-1 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Aleister Crowley · Answer

Turn 33. Bishop answers: "The Blood of the Osiris" was his word: (Meaning the Christ?) "The life, the tears, the tomb!"
\n
Closure is delayed at 1-1.
1-2 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Paulo Freire · Answer

Turn 34. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."
\n
The score moves to 1-2.
1-2 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Aleister Crowley · Answer

Turn 35. Bishop answers: "I am the priest, the sacrifice, the shrine, I am the love and life of the divine!"
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
1-2 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Jane Addams · Move

Turn 36. Pass. "BULLOCK, Ph.D., Assistant Professor of Economics, Williams College. *Social Control: A Survey of the Foundations of Order*."
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
1-2 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Augustine of Hippo · Move

Turn 37. Pass. "Human friendship also is endeared with a sweet tie, by reason of the unity formed of many souls."
\n
The move answers pressure.
1-2 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Jane Addams · Move

Turn 38. Advance. "Literature, too, portrays an equally absorbing though better adjusted desire to know all kinds of life."
\n
The move answers pressure.
1-2 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Plato · Question

Turn 39. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
1-2 · SOC (Jane Addams) · John Maynard Keynes · Question

Turn 40. Knight asks: "Those who are not in favour of drastic changes in the existing organisation of society believe that these arrangements, being in accord with human nature, have great advantages?"
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
1-2 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Omar Khayyam · Answer

Turn 41. Bishop answers: "That means the stronger reading is likely in this direction under pressure."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
1-3 · SOC (Jane Addams) · John Maynard Keynes · Question

Turn 42. Knight asks: "Will the charm work still, when the stock of statesmen's credibility, accumulated before these times, is getting exhausted?"
\n
The score moves to 1-3.
1-3 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Augustine of Hippo · Move

Turn 43. Save. "See where the impotent soul lies along, that is not yet stayed up by the solidity of truth!"
\n
Closure is delayed at 1-3.
1-3 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Mary Wollstonecraft · Move

Turn 44. Pass. "They may be convenient slaves, but slavery will have its constant effect, degrading the master and the abject dependent."
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
1-3 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Augustine of Hippo · Move

Turn 45. Advance. "And not being able to see these in the mind, I thought I could not see my mind."
\n
The move answers pressure.
1-3 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Jane Addams · Move

Turn 46. Save. "The neighborhood mind is at once confronted not only by the difference of method, but by an absolute clashing of two ethical standards."
\n
Closure is delayed at 1-3.
1-3 · META (Augustine of Hippo) · Plato · Question

Turn 47. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The move answers pressure.
1-3 · SOC (Jane Addams) · Mary Wollstonecraft · Move

Turn 48. Advance. "For surely, sir, you will not assert, that a duty can be binding which is not founded on reason".
\n
The move answers pressure.

Board Record

Match Shape

Discourse B (0.850); aesthetic B (0.862); repetition 0.218. Move mix: 12 pass, 15 advance, 14 challenge, 4 claim, 3 save.

Turn 4
Checked Bishop Desiderius Erasmus tests the opposing line.
Turn 10
Checked Bishop Desiderius Erasmus presses a claim.
Turn 33
Checked Bishop Aleister Crowley is denied closure.
Turn 34
Checked Bishop Paulo Freire presses a claim.

Full Call Sheet

Turn	Score	Action	Call	Relevance
1	0-0	Advance	Bishop Omar Khayyam develops the line.	0.908
2	0-0	Pass	Bishop Desiderius Erasmus re-centers the question.	0.803
3	0-0	Pass	Omar Khayyam releases to Queen Teresa of Avila, who re-centers the question.	0.980
4	0-0	Challenge	Checked Bishop Desiderius Erasmus tests the opposing line.	0.668
5	0-0	Advance	King Augustine of Hippo develops the line.	0.960
6	0-0	Advance	Checked Bishop Desiderius Erasmus develops the line.	0.808
7	0-0	Pass	King Augustine of Hippo re-centers the question.	0.936
8	0-0	Challenge	Checked Bishop Desiderius Erasmus tests the opposing line.	0.852
9	0-0	Advance	Checked King Augustine of Hippo develops the line.	0.964
10	0-1	Claim	Checked Bishop Desiderius Erasmus presses a claim.	0.950
11	0-1	Pass	Augustine of Hippo releases to Bishop Aleister Crowley, who re-centers the question.	0.921
12	0-1	Pass	Bishop Paulo Freire re-centers the question.	0.908
13	0-1	Advance	Checked Bishop Aleister Crowley develops the line.	0.865
14	0-1	Challenge	Checked Bishop Paulo Freire tests the opposing line.	1.000
15	0-1	Pass	Knight Plato re-centers the question.	0.835
16	0-1	Pass	Paulo Freire releases to Queen Mary Wollstonecraft, who re-centers the question.	0.893
17	0-1	Advance	Plato releases to Bishop Omar Khayyam, who develops the line.	0.965
18	0-1	Advance	Mary Wollstonecraft releases to King Jane Addams, who develops the line.	0.971
19	0-1	Challenge	Omar Khayyam releases to Bishop Aleister Crowley, who tests the opposing line.	1.000
20	0-1	Challenge	Jane Addams releases to Bishop Paulo Freire, who tests the opposing line.	0.753
21	0-1	Advance	Aleister Crowley releases to King Augustine of Hippo, who develops the line.	1.000
22	0-1	Advance	Paulo Freire releases to Queen Mary Wollstonecraft, who develops the line.	0.837
23	0-1	Challenge	Checked King Augustine of Hippo tests the opposing line.	1.000
24	0-1	Challenge	Checked Queen Mary Wollstonecraft tests the opposing line.	1.000
25	0-1	Advance	Augustine of Hippo releases to Bishop Omar Khayyam, who develops the line.	1.000
26	0-1	Pass	Mary Wollstonecraft releases to Knight John Maynard Keynes, who re-centers the question.	0.980
27	0-1	Challenge	Omar Khayyam releases to Bishop Aleister Crowley, who tests the opposing line.	0.776
28	0-1	Challenge	Checked Knight John Maynard Keynes tests the opposing line.	1.000
29	1-1	Claim	Aleister Crowley releases to Bishop Omar Khayyam, who presses a claim.	0.984
30	1-1	Advance	Checked Knight John Maynard Keynes develops the line.	0.978
31	1-1	Challenge	Bishop Aleister Crowley tests the opposing line.	0.906
32	1-1	Challenge	John Maynard Keynes releases to Bishop Paulo Freire, who tests the opposing line.	1.000
33	1-1	Save	Checked Bishop Aleister Crowley is denied closure.	1.000
34	1-2	Claim	Checked Bishop Paulo Freire presses a claim.	0.930
35	1-2	Challenge	Checked Bishop Aleister Crowley tests the opposing line.	0.899
36	1-2	Pass	King Jane Addams re-centers the question.	0.847
37	1-2	Pass	Aleister Crowley releases to King Augustine of Hippo, who re-centers the question.	1.000
38	1-2	Advance	Checked King Jane Addams develops the line.	0.992
39	1-2	Advance	Knight Plato develops the line.	1.000
40	1-2	Challenge	Jane Addams releases to Knight John Maynard Keynes, who tests the opposing line.	0.905
41	1-2	Challenge	Plato releases to Bishop Omar Khayyam, who tests the opposing line.	0.829
42	1-3	Claim	Checked Knight John Maynard Keynes presses a claim.	0.942
43	1-3	Save	Omar Khayyam releases to King Augustine of Hippo, who is denied closure.	1.000
44	1-3	Pass	Queen Mary Wollstonecraft re-centers the question.	1.000
45	1-3	Advance	Checked King Augustine of Hippo develops the line.	0.821
46	1-3	Save	Mary Wollstonecraft releases to King Jane Addams, who is denied closure.	0.997
47	1-3	Pass	Augustine of Hippo releases to Knight Plato, who re-centers the question.	0.851
48	1-3	Advance	Jane Addams releases to Queen Mary Wollstonecraft, who develops the line.	1.000