Group A · Match 05

HEAL (Carl Jung) vs ELA (Henry David Thoreau)

Result 1-0. Outcome: HEAL (Carl Jung).

Result1-0

OutcomeHEAL (Carl Jung)

DiscourseB 0.809

AestheticB 0.843

Checked moves34

Bead passes20

Realtime Call

Turn 1

0-0

Kickoff

Speed

0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Carl Jung · Move

Turn 1. Pass. "I thought one must first work modestly for years in such a field before one might dare to criticize."
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Henry David Thoreau · Move

Turn 2. Pass. King Henry David Thoreau re-centers the question.
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Mary mother of Jesus · Move

Turn 3. Advance. Carl Jung releases to Queen Mary mother of Jesus, who develops the line.
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Buddha · Move

Turn 4. Advance. Queen Buddha develops the line.
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Avicenna · Answer

Turn 5. Bishop answers: "The first is the principle (or source and origin), and the second is the doing and the effect (or trace)."
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Henry David Thoreau · Move

Turn 6. Pass. King Henry David Thoreau re-centers the question.
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Avicenna · Answer

Turn 7. Bishop answers: "Establishing the Proofs necessary for affirming the Essentiality of the Speaking (Rational) Soul, by the logical method. 10."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Henry David Thoreau · Move

Turn 8. Advance. Checked King Henry David Thoreau develops the line.
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Anna Freud · Question

Turn 9. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Henry David Thoreau · Move

Turn 10. Advance. Checked King Henry David Thoreau develops the line.
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Carl Jung · Move

Turn 11. Advance. "For the troublesome work of translation I am greatly indebted to my assistant, Miss M."
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Julian Huxley · Answer

Turn 12. Bishop answers: "It is beginning to reach down from observation to experimental analysis, and from experimental analysis to grasp of principle."
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · R. D. Laing · Question

Turn 13. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Buddha · Move

Turn 14. Advance. Julian Huxley releases to Queen Buddha, who develops the line.
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Anna Freud · Question

Turn 15. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Julian Huxley · Answer

Turn 16. Bishop answers: "In pre-human evolution, the blind chances of variation and the blind sifting of natural selection have directed the course of evolution and of progress."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Anna Freud · Question

Turn 17. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

Turn 18. Bishop answers: "So the core point is this: the line from F6->E5 is the better constraint."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · R. D. Laing · Question

Turn 19. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

Turn 20. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Mary mother of Jesus · Move

Turn 21. Advance. R. D. Laing releases to Queen Mary mother of Jesus, who develops the line.
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

Turn 22. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."
\n
Closure is delayed at 0-0.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · R. D. Laing · Question

Turn 23. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

Turn 24. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Mary mother of Jesus · Move

Turn 25. Advance. R. D. Laing releases to Queen Mary mother of Jesus, who develops the line.
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Buddha · Move

Turn 26. Challenge. Stephen Jay Gould releases to Queen Buddha, who tests the opposing line.
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Avicenna · Answer

Turn 27. Bishop answers: "Memoir on the Human Soul from the Stage of its Beginning to the Stage of its Perfection. 9."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Buddha · Move

Turn 28. Save. Checked Queen Buddha is denied closure.
\n
Closure is delayed at 0-0.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Anna Freud · Question

Turn 29. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Buddha · Move

Turn 30. Advance. Checked Queen Buddha develops the line.
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Carl Jung · Move

Turn 31. Challenge. "But Truth, has many faces; and scarcely any poet (except perhaps Shakespeare) has come within measurable distance of expressing every aspect of the human character."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Henry David Thoreau · Move

Turn 32. Pass. Buddha releases to King Henry David Thoreau, who re-centers the question.
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Carl Jung · Move

Turn 33. Advance. "But then this enjoins upon ourselves the duty of applying a proper criticism, grounded upon a practical knowledge of the facts."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Henry David Thoreau · Move

Turn 34. Advance. Checked King Henry David Thoreau develops the line.
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Avicenna · Answer

Turn 35. Bishop answers: "Thus then we have divided (described) the generic soul, and defined it--which is what we had undertaken."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · John Maynard Smith · Question

Turn 36. Knight asks: "What assumption are we testing if knight keeps the focus here?"
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Gregory Bateson · Answer

Turn 37. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

Turn 38. Bishop answers: "So the core point is this: the line from C4->B5 is the better constraint."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Anna Freud · Question

Turn 39. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Buddha · Move

Turn 40. Advance. Stephen Jay Gould releases to Queen Buddha, who develops the line.
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Anna Freud · Question

Turn 41. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · John Maynard Smith · Question

Turn 42. Knight asks: "What assumption are we testing if knight keeps the focus here?"
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
0-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Avicenna · Answer

Turn 43. Bishop answers: "The first is the principle (or source and origin), and the second is the doing and the effect (or trace)."
\n
The move answers pressure.
0-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · John Maynard Smith · Question

Turn 44. Knight asks: "What assumption are we testing if knight keeps the focus here?"
\n
The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.
1-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · Avicenna · Answer

Turn 45. Bishop answers: "Establishing the Proofs necessary for affirming the Essentiality of the Speaking (Rational) Soul, by the logical method. 10."
\n
The score moves to 1-0.
1-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Henry David Thoreau · Move

Turn 46. Save. John Maynard Smith releases to King Henry David Thoreau, who is denied closure.
\n
Closure is delayed at 1-0.
1-0 · HEAL (Carl Jung) · R. D. Laing · Question

Turn 47. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.
1-0 · ELA (Henry David Thoreau) · Stephen Jay Gould · Answer

Turn 48. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."
\n
The inquiry keeps moving.

Board Record

Match Shape

Discourse B (0.809); aesthetic B (0.843); repetition 0.207. Move mix: 10 pass, 22 advance, 12 challenge, 1 claim, 3 save.

Turn 1
King Carl Jung re-centers the question.
Turn 7
Checked Bishop Avicenna tests the opposing line.
Turn 22
Checked Bishop Stephen Jay Gould is denied closure.
Turn 45
Checked Bishop Avicenna presses a claim.

Full Call Sheet

Turn	Score	Action	Call	Relevance
1	0-0	Pass	King Carl Jung re-centers the question.	1.000
2	0-0	Pass	King Henry David Thoreau re-centers the question.	0.766
3	0-0	Advance	Carl Jung releases to Queen Mary mother of Jesus, who develops the line.	0.822
4	0-0	Advance	Queen Buddha develops the line.	0.968
5	0-0	Pass	Bishop Avicenna re-centers the question.	0.776
6	0-0	Pass	King Henry David Thoreau re-centers the question.	0.965
7	0-0	Challenge	Checked Bishop Avicenna tests the opposing line.	0.703
8	0-0	Advance	Checked King Henry David Thoreau develops the line.	0.848
9	0-0	Pass	Avicenna releases to Knight Anna Freud, who re-centers the question.	0.729
10	0-0	Advance	Checked King Henry David Thoreau develops the line.	0.892
11	0-0	Advance	King Carl Jung develops the line.	1.000
12	0-0	Pass	Bishop Julian Huxley re-centers the question.	0.870
13	0-0	Challenge	Carl Jung releases to Knight R. D. Laing, who tests the opposing line.	0.739
14	0-0	Advance	Julian Huxley releases to Queen Buddha, who develops the line.	0.853
15	0-0	Challenge	R. D. Laing releases to Knight Anna Freud, who tests the opposing line.	0.873
16	0-0	Challenge	Buddha releases to Bishop Julian Huxley, who tests the opposing line.	1.000
17	0-0	Advance	Checked Knight Anna Freud develops the line.	0.942
18	0-0	Advance	Julian Huxley releases to Bishop Stephen Jay Gould, who develops the line.	0.940
19	0-0	Pass	Anna Freud releases to Knight R. D. Laing, who re-centers the question.	0.964
20	0-0	Challenge	Checked Bishop Stephen Jay Gould tests the opposing line.	0.835
21	0-0	Advance	R. D. Laing releases to Queen Mary mother of Jesus, who develops the line.	0.970
22	0-0	Save	Checked Bishop Stephen Jay Gould is denied closure.	1.000
23	0-0	Advance	Mary mother of Jesus releases to Knight R. D. Laing, who develops the line.	0.981
24	0-0	Advance	Checked Bishop Stephen Jay Gould develops the line.	1.000
25	0-0	Advance	R. D. Laing releases to Queen Mary mother of Jesus, who develops the line.	0.755
26	0-0	Challenge	Stephen Jay Gould releases to Queen Buddha, who tests the opposing line.	1.000
27	0-0	Challenge	Bishop Avicenna tests the opposing line.	0.806
28	0-0	Save	Checked Queen Buddha is denied closure.	0.657
29	0-0	Challenge	Knight Anna Freud tests the opposing line.	0.971
30	0-0	Advance	Checked Queen Buddha develops the line.	0.883
31	0-0	Challenge	King Carl Jung tests the opposing line.	0.972
32	0-0	Pass	Buddha releases to King Henry David Thoreau, who re-centers the question.	1.000
33	0-0	Advance	Checked King Carl Jung develops the line.	0.965
34	0-0	Advance	Checked King Henry David Thoreau develops the line.	0.959
35	0-0	Advance	Carl Jung releases to Bishop Avicenna, who develops the line.	0.790
36	0-0	Pass	Knight John Maynard Smith re-centers the question.	0.833
37	0-0	Challenge	Avicenna releases to Bishop Gregory Bateson, who tests the opposing line.	0.631
38	0-0	Advance	John Maynard Smith releases to Bishop Stephen Jay Gould, who develops the line.	1.000
39	0-0	Challenge	Gregory Bateson releases to Knight Anna Freud, who tests the opposing line.	0.852
40	0-0	Advance	Stephen Jay Gould releases to Queen Buddha, who develops the line.	0.955
41	0-0	Advance	Checked Knight Anna Freud develops the line.	0.949
42	0-0	Advance	Knight John Maynard Smith develops the line.	0.891
43	0-0	Pass	Anna Freud releases to Bishop Avicenna, who re-centers the question.	1.000
44	0-0	Challenge	Checked Knight John Maynard Smith tests the opposing line.	0.850
45	1-0	Claim	Checked Bishop Avicenna presses a claim.	0.843
46	1-0	Save	John Maynard Smith releases to King Henry David Thoreau, who is denied closure.	1.000
47	1-0	Advance	Knight R. D. Laing develops the line.	0.952
48	1-0	Advance	Bishop Stephen Jay Gould develops the line.	0.908