Group B · Match 14

MATH (Lewis Carroll) vs AINS (George Kelly)

Result 1-0. Outcome: MATH (Lewis Carroll).

Result1-0
OutcomeMATH (Lewis Carroll)
DiscourseB 0.824
AestheticB 0.850
Checked moves31
Bead passes13

Realtime Call

Turn 1
0-0
Kickoff

  1. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Lewis Carroll · Move

    Turn 1. Pass. "And, in the present work, the difficulties of the "5 Liars" Problem, at p."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  2. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Philip K. Dick · Question

    Turn 2. Knight asks: "Buildings and ramps and open-air machinery; the city was sealed in a protective dust-proof envelope?"

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  3. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Lewis Carroll · Move

    Turn 3. Advance. "Soriteses", will, I fear, be condemned as "bad English", unless I say a word in its defence."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  4. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Confucius · Answer

    Turn 4. Bishop answers: "Let’s take that test seriously; here is how it holds together."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  5. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Euclid · Answer

    Turn 5. Bishop answers: "The Solution of a problem is the method of construction which accomplishes the required end."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  6. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Confucius · Answer

    Turn 6. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  7. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Euclid · Answer

    Turn 7. Bishop answers: "In compiling his work the Editor has received invaluable assistance from the late Rev."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  8. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Philip K. Dick · Question

    Turn 8. Knight asks: "We have all their planets except the inner Orion string--not that they're worth much, but it's the principle of the thing?"

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  9. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Euclid · Answer

    Turn 9. Bishop answers: "An acute angle is one which is less than a right angle, as A . x v i ."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  10. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · John McCarthy · Question

    Turn 10. Knight asks: "What assumption are we testing if knight keeps the focus here?"

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  11. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Euclid · Answer

    Turn 11. Bishop answers: "A circle may be described from any centre, and with any distance from that centre as radius."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  12. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Maria Montessori · Move

    Turn 12. Pass. "Instead, we must proceed by a method which shall tend to make possible to the child complete liberty."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  13. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · René Descartes · Move

    Turn 13. Pass. "For to be possessed of a vigorous mind is not enough; the prime requisite is rightly to apply it."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  14. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Confucius · Answer

    Turn 14. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  15. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · René Descartes · Move

    Turn 15. Advance. "I esteemed eloquence highly, and was in raptures with poesy; but I thought that both were gifts of nature rather than fruits of study."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  16. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Confucius · Answer

    Turn 16. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

    \n

    Closure is delayed at 0-0.

  17. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz · Answer

    Turn 17. Bishop answers: "Et quand on envisage la question de ce biais, les difficultés disparaissent du même coup."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  18. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Confucius · Answer

    Turn 18. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  19. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Euclid · Answer

    Turn 19. Bishop answers: "The Solution of a problem is the method of construction which accomplishes the required end."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  20. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Confucius · Answer

    Turn 20. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  21. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Lewis Carroll · Move

    Turn 21. Challenge. "And then, you know, one is so _patient_ with one's self: one _never_ gets irritated at one's own stupidity!"

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  22. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · John McCarthy · Question

    Turn 22. Knight asks: "What assumption are we testing if knight keeps the focus here?"

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  23. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · René Descartes · Move

    Turn 23. Advance. "For to hold converse with those of other ages and to travel, are almost the same thing."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  24. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Maria Montessori · Move

    Turn 24. Advance. "DISCIPLINE The pedagogical method of _observation_ has for its base the _liberty_ of the child; and _liberty is activity_."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  25. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz · Answer

    Turn 25. Bishop answers: "La multiplicité sans borne, c'est aussi ce que suppose la nature même de la monade."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  26. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Maria Montessori · Move

    Turn 26. Challenge. "The general question of individual liberty is thus reduced to a series of practical problems of adjustment."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  27. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · René Descartes · Move

    Turn 27. Challenge. "I was thus led to infer that the ground of our opinions is far more custom and example than any certain knowledge."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  28. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Isaac Asimov · Answer

    Turn 28. Bishop answers: "There had been another change, though, that was significant enough and that was in the colors."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  29. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · René Descartes · Move

    Turn 29. Advance. "For to be possessed of a vigorous mind is not enough; the prime requisite is rightly to apply it."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  30. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Isaac Asimov · Answer

    Turn 30. Bishop answers: "Good Lord, what man in Robotics has not been investigated and cleared to death by your people."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  31. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · René Descartes · Move

    Turn 31. Advance. "I esteemed eloquence highly, and was in raptures with poesy; but I thought that both were gifts of nature rather than fruits of study."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  32. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · George Kelly · Move

    Turn 32. Pass. Isaac Asimov releases to King George Kelly, who re-centers the question.

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  33. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Lewis Carroll · Move

    Turn 33. Pass. "And, all the while, you have been leaving unexplored a perfect _mine_ of wealth."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  34. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Philip K. Dick · Question

    Turn 34. Knight asks: "Tony noticed the Pas-udeti's sudden change of expression, and he was puzzled?"

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  35. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Lewis Carroll · Move

    Turn 35. Advance. "And, in the present work, the difficulties of the "5 Liars" Problem, at p."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  36. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Philip K. Dick · Question

    Turn 36. Knight asks: "The hot dust lapped at his ankles; he automatically moved his feet and slapped at his trousers?"

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  37. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Lewis Carroll · Move

    Turn 37. Challenge. "Soriteses", will, I fear, be condemned as "bad English", unless I say a word in its defence."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  38. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Philip K. Dick · Question

    Turn 38. Knight asks: "Buildings and ramps and open-air machinery; the city was sealed in a protective dust-proof envelope?"

    \n

    Closure is delayed at 0-0.

  39. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Lewis Carroll · Move

    Turn 39. Advance. "And then, you know, one is so _patient_ with one's self: one _never_ gets irritated at one's own stupidity!"

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  40. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Isaac Asimov · Answer

    Turn 40. Bishop answers: "Elias Lynn was a large man, almost charmingly homely, with pale blue eyes that bulged a bit."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  41. 0-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Lewis Carroll · Move

    Turn 41. Pass. "And, all the while, you have been leaving unexplored a perfect _mine_ of wealth."

    \n

    The move answers pressure.

  42. 0-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Confucius · Answer

    Turn 42. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

    \n

    Closure is delayed at 0-0.

  43. 1-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz · Answer

    Turn 43. Bishop answers: "En les introduisant à la place du continu, l'on ne change rien qu'aux yeux de l'imagination."

    \n

    The score moves to 1-0.

  44. 1-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Confucius · Answer

    Turn 44. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

  45. 1-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz · Answer

    Turn 45. Bishop answers: "Et l'on n'observe pas que c'est «une fiction, que la nature ne souffre point»."

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  46. 1-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Maria Montessori · Move

    Turn 46. Save. "The principle in this case consists of the affirmation of the child's need for social training."

    \n

    Closure is delayed at 1-0.

  47. 1-0 · MATH (Lewis Carroll) · Blaise Pascal · Question

    Turn 47. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

    \n

    The inquiry keeps moving.

  48. 1-0 · AINS (George Kelly) · Philip K. Dick · Question

    Turn 48. Knight asks: "We have all their planets except the inner Orion string--not that they're worth much, but it's the principle of the thing?"

    \n

    The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Board Record

Match Shape

Discourse B (0.824); aesthetic B (0.850); repetition 0.207. Move mix: 13 pass, 18 advance, 12 challenge, 1 claim, 4 save.

Full Call Sheet

TurnScoreActionCallRelevance
10-0PassKing Lewis Carroll re-centers the question.0.859
20-0AdvanceKnight Philip K. Dick develops the line.0.648
30-0AdvanceChecked King Lewis Carroll develops the line.0.850
40-0AdvancePhilip K. Dick releases to Bishop Confucius, who develops the line.0.745
50-0PassLewis Carroll releases to Bishop Euclid, who re-centers the question.0.988
60-0ChallengeChecked Bishop Confucius tests the opposing line.1.000
70-0AdvanceChecked Bishop Euclid develops the line.1.000
80-0PassConfucius releases to Knight Philip K. Dick, who re-centers the question.1.000
90-0ChallengeChecked Bishop Euclid tests the opposing line.0.856
100-0AdvanceKnight John McCarthy develops the line.0.968
110-0AdvanceChecked Bishop Euclid develops the line.0.872
120-0PassJohn McCarthy releases to Queen Maria Montessori, who re-centers the question.1.000
130-0PassEuclid releases to Queen René Descartes, who re-centers the question.0.834
140-0ChallengeBishop Confucius tests the opposing line.0.706
150-0AdvanceQueen René Descartes develops the line.0.886
160-0SaveChecked Bishop Confucius is denied closure.0.874
170-0PassBishop Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz re-centers the question.0.946
180-0AdvanceChecked Bishop Confucius develops the line.0.984
190-0AdvanceBishop Euclid develops the line.0.935
200-0ChallengeChecked Bishop Confucius tests the opposing line.0.815
210-0ChallengeEuclid releases to King Lewis Carroll, who tests the opposing line.1.000
220-0PassKnight John McCarthy re-centers the question.0.951
230-0AdvanceQueen René Descartes develops the line.0.898
240-0AdvanceJohn McCarthy releases to Queen Maria Montessori, who develops the line.1.000
250-0AdvanceRené Descartes releases to Bishop Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz, who develops the line.0.736
260-0ChallengeChecked Queen Maria Montessori tests the opposing line.0.800
270-0ChallengeGottfried Wilhelm Leibniz releases to Queen René Descartes, who tests the opposing line.0.799
280-0PassMaria Montessori releases to Bishop Isaac Asimov, who re-centers the question.0.865
290-0AdvanceChecked Queen René Descartes develops the line.0.746
300-0ChallengeChecked Bishop Isaac Asimov tests the opposing line.0.886
310-0AdvanceChecked Queen René Descartes develops the line.0.959
320-0PassIsaac Asimov releases to King George Kelly, who re-centers the question.0.877
330-0PassKing Lewis Carroll re-centers the question.0.932
340-0AdvanceKnight Philip K. Dick develops the line.1.000
350-0AdvanceKing Lewis Carroll develops the line.0.991
360-0ChallengeChecked Knight Philip K. Dick tests the opposing line.0.842
370-0ChallengeChecked King Lewis Carroll tests the opposing line.1.000
380-0SaveChecked Knight Philip K. Dick is denied closure.0.922
390-0AdvanceChecked King Lewis Carroll develops the line.1.000
400-0PassBishop Isaac Asimov re-centers the question.1.000
410-0PassChecked King Lewis Carroll re-centers the question.0.959
420-0SaveIsaac Asimov releases to Bishop Confucius, who is denied closure.0.982
431-0ClaimBishop Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz presses a claim.0.929
441-0ChallengeChecked Bishop Confucius tests the opposing line.1.000
451-0AdvanceBishop Gottfried Wilhelm Leibniz develops the line.0.966
461-0SaveConfucius releases to Queen Maria Montessori, who is denied closure.1.000
471-0PassKnight Blaise Pascal re-centers the question.0.800
481-0ChallengeKnight Philip K. Dick tests the opposing line.0.864