HEAL (Carl Jung) vs ELA (Henry David Thoreau)

Turn 1. Pass. "I thought one must first work modestly for years in such a field before one might dare to criticize."

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 2. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 3. Advance. Carl Jung releases to Queen Mary mother of Jesus, who develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 4. Advance. Stephen Jay Gould releases to Queen Buddha, who develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 5. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 6. Bishop answers: "It is beginning to reach down from observation to experimental analysis, and from experimental analysis to grasp of principle."

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 7. Advance. Queen Mary mother of Jesus develops the line.

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 8. Bishop answers: "In pre-human evolution, the blind chances of variation and the blind sifting of natural selection have directed the course of evolution and of progress."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 9. Challenge. Checked Queen Mary mother of Jesus tests the opposing line.

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 10. Bishop answers: "Julian Huxley framed this well; the inference is that we should move here."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 11. Pass. "For the troublesome work of translation I am greatly indebted to my assistant, Miss M."

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 12. Advance. Stephen Jay Gould releases to Queen Buddha, who develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 13. Advance. "But Truth, has many faces; and scarcely any poet (except perhaps Shakespeare) has come within measurable distance of expressing every aspect of the human character."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 14. Bishop answers: "Let’s take that test seriously; here is how it holds together."

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 15. Pass. Carl Jung releases to Queen Mary mother of Jesus, who re-centers the question.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 16. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

Closure is delayed at 0-0.

Turn 17. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 18. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 19. Advance. Queen Mary mother of Jesus develops the line.

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 20. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

The score moves to 0-1.

Turn 21. Pass. "But then this enjoins upon ourselves the duty of applying a proper criticism, grounded upon a practical knowledge of the facts."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 22. Knight asks: "What assumption are we testing if knight keeps the focus here?"

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 23. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 24. Challenge. John Maynard Smith releases to Queen Buddha, who tests the opposing line.

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 25. Advance. "I thought one must first work modestly for years in such a field before one might dare to criticize."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 26. Advance. Checked Queen Buddha develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 27. Bishop answers: "I can defend it on this basis, and that is why this answer matters."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 28. Bishop answers: "The one, that is to say, remained in essence a quantitative change so far as concerns the real life of man; the other can be a qualitative change."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 29. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 30. Advance. Julian Huxley releases to King Henry David Thoreau, who develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 31. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 32. Challenge. Checked King Henry David Thoreau tests the opposing line.

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 33. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 34. Advance. Checked King Henry David Thoreau develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 35. Bishop answers: "Anna Freud framed this well; the inference is that we should move here."

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 36. Pass. Henry David Thoreau releases to Queen Buddha, who re-centers the question.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 37. Bishop answers: "The first is the principle (or source and origin), and the second is the doing and the effect (or trace)."

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 38. Advance. Checked Queen Buddha develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 39. Advance. Avicenna releases to Queen Mary mother of Jesus, who develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 40. Bishop answers: "Buddha framed this well; the inference is that we should move here."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 41. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 42. Bishop answers: "Men are educated to be self-reliant and enterprising in the details of life, but dependent, unreflective, _laissez-faire_ about life itself."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 43. Bishop answers: "So the core point is this: the line from D5->D5 is the better constraint."

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 44. Pass. Julian Huxley releases to King Henry David Thoreau, who re-centers the question.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 45. Claim. "For the troublesome work of translation I am greatly indebted to my assistant, Miss M."

The score moves to 1-1.

Turn 46. Save. Checked King Henry David Thoreau is denied closure.

Closure is delayed at 1-1.

Turn 47. Bishop answers: "That means the stronger reading is likely in this direction."

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 48. Pass. Checked King Henry David Thoreau re-centers the question.

The move answers pressure.

Shootout round 1. Mary mother of Jesus for HEAL (Carl Jung): goal. Shootout score 1-0.

Shootout round 1. Buddha for ELA (Henry David Thoreau): save. Shootout score 1-0.

Shootout round 2. Carl Jung for HEAL (Carl Jung): "But Truth, has many faces; and scarcely any poet (except perhaps Shakespeare) has come within measurable distance of expressing every aspect of the human character.". Shootout score 2-0.

Shootout round 2. Stephen Jay Gould for ELA (Henry David Thoreau): goal. Shootout score 2-1.

Shootout round 3. Anna Freud for HEAL (Carl Jung): goal. Shootout score 3-1.

Shootout round 3. Henry David Thoreau for ELA (Henry David Thoreau): save. Shootout score 3-1.

Shootout round 4. R. D. Laing for HEAL (Carl Jung): save. Shootout score 3-1.

Shootout round 4. Julian Huxley for ELA (Henry David Thoreau): "It is beginning to reach down from observation to experimental analysis, and from experimental analysis to grasp of principle.". Shootout score 3-2.

Shootout round 5. Avicenna for HEAL (Carl Jung): "Establishing the Proofs necessary for affirming the Essentiality of the Speaking (Rational) Soul, by the logical method. 10.". Shootout score 4-2.

Shootout round 5. John Maynard Smith for ELA (Henry David Thoreau): save. Shootout score 4-2.