CEF (Leonardo da Vinci) vs NAT (Albert Einstein)

Turn 1. Pass. Queen Marie Curie re-centers the question.

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 2. Advance. Queen David Bohm develops the line.

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 3. Bishop answers: "So the core point is this: the line from C6->D5 is the better constraint."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 4. Bishop answers: "Naturalists continually refer to external conditions, such as climate, food, etc., as the only possible cause of variation."

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 5. Advance. Stafford Beer releases to Queen Marie Curie, who develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 6. Advance. Charles Darwin releases to Queen David Bohm, who develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 7. Bishop answers: "The economy of human time is the next advantage of machinery in manufactures."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 8. Challenge. Checked Queen David Bohm tests the opposing line.

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 9. Bishop answers: "In pointing out the advantages of tools, we shall commence with some of the simplest. 11."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 10. Knight asks: "Natural philosophy, which preceded all exact observation in antiquity, is a natural, but not unfrequently ill-directed, effort of reason?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 11. Bishop answers: "The simpler machines are often merely one or more tools placed in a frame, and acted on by a moving power."

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 12. Bishop answers: "I need not enumerate the actual results which the last century gained by this work."

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 13. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 14. Bishop answers: "He had probably never dipped very deep in the latter subject, and that strengthened our doubts."

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 15. Advance. Nikola Tesla releases to King Leonardo da Vinci, who develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 16. Bishop answers: "From the strong principle of inheritance, any selected variety will tend to propagate its new and modified form."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 17. Advance. Leonardo da Vinci releases to Queen Marie Curie, who develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 18. Knight asks: "What assumption are we testing if Charles Darwin keeps the focus here?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 19. Challenge. Checked Queen Marie Curie tests the opposing line.

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 20. Bishop answers: "In the last chapter I shall give a brief recapitulation of the whole work, and a few concluding remarks."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 21. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 22. Bishop answers: "We now know that many of these hypotheses, which found favour in their day, far overshot the mark."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 23. Bishop answers: "Several of the principles which I have proposed, appear to me to have been unnoticed before."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 24. Knight asks: "That which is attained by observation and experiment (calling forth phenomena) leads, by analogy and induction, to a knowledge of 'empirical laws'; their gradual simplification and generalization?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 25. Bishop answers: "The economy of human time is the next advantage of machinery in manufactures."

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 26. Knight asks: "The 'existing' can not be absolutely separated in our contemplation of nature from the 'future'?"

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 27. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 28. Bishop answers: "Any change in the embryo or larva will almost certainly entail changes in the mature animal."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 29. Advance. Norbert Wiener releases to King Leonardo da Vinci, who develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 30. Bishop answers: "Naturalists continually refer to external conditions, such as climate, food, etc., as the only possible cause of variation."

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 31. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 32. Bishop answers: "From the strong principle of inheritance, any selected variety will tend to propagate its new and modified form."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 33. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 34. Pass. Queen David Bohm re-centers the question.

The inquiry keeps moving.

Turn 35. Bishop answers: "Nikola Tesla framed this well; the inference is that we should move here."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 36. Knight asks: "What assumption are we testing if David Bohm keeps the focus here?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 37. Advance. Stafford Beer releases to Queen Marie Curie, who develops the line.

The move answers pressure.

Turn 38. Knight asks: "Misunderstood popular knowledge, confounding cosmography with a mere encyclopedic enumeration of natural sciences?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 39. Challenge. Checked Queen Marie Curie tests the opposing line.

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 40. Knight asks: "What assumption are we testing if Alexander von Humboldt keeps the focus here?"

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 41. Bishop answers: "In pointing out the advantages of tools, we shall commence with some of the simplest. 11."

Closure is delayed at 0-0.

Turn 42. Knight asks: "What assumption are we testing if knight keeps the focus here?"

Closure is delayed at 0-0.

Turn 43. Bishop answers: "So the core point is this: the line from E4->F5 is the better constraint."

The move answers pressure.

Turn 44. Knight asks: "Natural philosophy, which preceded all exact observation in antiquity, is a natural, but not unfrequently ill-directed, effort of reason?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 45. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The move answers pressure.

Turn 46. Challenge. Alexander von Humboldt releases to Queen David Bohm, who tests the opposing line.

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 47. Knight asks: "If this line is valid, what would it imply for the other side to justify now?"

The challenge gives the next answer real work to do.

Turn 48. Save. Checked Queen David Bohm is denied closure.

Closure is delayed at 0-0.

Shootout round 1. Marie Curie for CEF (Leonardo da Vinci): goal. Shootout score 1-0.

Shootout round 1. David Bohm for NAT (Albert Einstein): save. Shootout score 1-0.

Shootout round 2. Stafford Beer for CEF (Leonardo da Vinci): save. Shootout score 1-0.

Shootout round 2. Charles Darwin for NAT (Albert Einstein): "In the last chapter I shall give a brief recapitulation of the whole work, and a few concluding remarks.". Shootout score 1-0.

Shootout round 3. Nikola Tesla for CEF (Leonardo da Vinci): save. Shootout score 1-0.

Shootout round 3. Alexander von Humboldt for NAT (Albert Einstein): "That which is attained by observation and experiment (calling forth phenomena) leads, by analogy and induction, to a knowledge of 'empirical laws'; their gradual simplification and generalization.". Shootout score 1-1.

Shootout round 4. Norbert Wiener for CEF (Leonardo da Vinci): goal. Shootout score 2-1.

Shootout round 4. Wolfgang Pauli for NAT (Albert Einstein): goal. Shootout score 2-2.

Shootout round 5. Charles Babbage for CEF (Leonardo da Vinci): "The simpler machines are often merely one or more tools placed in a frame, and acted on by a moving power.". Shootout score 2-2.

Shootout round 5. Hermann von Helmholtz for NAT (Albert Einstein): "Owing to the Reformation, intellectual life had lost its old stability and cohesion; everything appeared in a new light, and new questions arose.". Shootout score 2-2.

Shootout round 6. Leonardo da Vinci for CEF (Leonardo da Vinci): save. Shootout score 2-2.

Shootout round 6. Albert Einstein for NAT (Albert Einstein): "It is only with reluctance that man's desire for knowledge endures a dualism of this kind.". Shootout score 2-3.